Carpet does not fail on a particular day. It wears out a little at a time, in the hallway first, and because you walk on it every day the change is easy to miss until a visitor's face or a listing photo makes it obvious.
Not every tired-looking carpet needs replacing, though. Some problems are the end of the carpet, and some are a cleaning or a repair. Here is how to tell which you have.
The signs that mean it is done
Traffic lanes that cleaning will not lift. The path down the hall, the strip in front of the sofa, the route from the door to the kitchen. When the pile in those lanes is flattened and dull and stays that way after a good professional cleaning, the fibers have lost their twist and crushed. Cleaning removes dirt. It cannot put back the shape of the fiber. Choosing carpet that lasts explains why twist and density decide how long that takes.
The pad has given out. Walk barefoot from the middle of a hallway into a closet. If the hallway feels thin and hard, or crunchy, or lumpy, while the closet feels soft, the pad under the traffic areas has broken down. A worn-out pad also speeds up wear on the carpet above it, because the carpet is no longer cushioned.
Stains and odors that keep coming back. Pet accidents in particular soak through the carpet into the pad, and sometimes into the subfloor. Cleaning the surface takes the stain away for a while, then it wicks back up. If a smell returns every time the weather turns damp, it is coming from underneath. Pet-friendly flooring covers what to choose if that is the reason you are replacing.
Seams and edges coming apart. A seam you can see opening, edges fraying along a doorway, or the backing showing through on the nose of a stair step are wear that does not repair well.
Ripples that keep returning. A ripple can often be re-stretched. If it has been stretched before and the ripples came back, or the backing is separating from the face of the carpet, it is usually at the end. Rippled carpet goes through that decision in detail.
It got soaked. Carpet and pad that sat wet from a leak or a flood are a different case from ordinary wear. A leak got under the floor covers what to do first.
It is holding more than it should. Old carpet holds a lot of dust and fine grit deep in the pile and the pad, below where a vacuum reaches. Some households notice that more than others, and it is a common reason people decide to change it.
The signs that do not necessarily mean replace
One stain. A single spot, even a bad one, is often something a professional cleaner can treat, and a small patch can sometimes be cut in from a closet if a remnant exists.
A small ripple. In a carpet that is otherwise in good shape, a re-stretch is often the better use of money.
Light and dark patches that change with the angle. Shading, where the pile lies in different directions and catches the light differently, is a characteristic of many cut pile carpets, not a defect or a sign of wear.
Fluff in the vacuum from a new carpet. Many new carpets shed loose fibers for a while after installation. It settles down.
A color you have stopped liking. If the carpet is sound and the only problem is that it is dated, it is a style decision rather than a repair. If you are getting ready to sell, replacing flooring before selling gives a straight answer on whether it is worth it.
How long carpet lasts
There is no single number, and anyone who gives you one without seeing the carpet is guessing. A low-density carpet on a soft pad in a busy hall with a dog can look finished in a few years. A dense, well-twisted carpet on a good pad in a guest bedroom can go a very long time. Density, twist, the pad and the traffic matter far more than the age.
That is also why carpet often wears unevenly. The hall and the stairs give out years before the bedrooms, which raises the question of replacing only part of the house.
A few checks you can do yourself
- Compare the lanes with the edges. Look at the color and the pile in the middle of the hall, then at the edge of the same hall against the baseboard. The difference is the wear.
- Look under furniture. Slide a chair or a dresser and compare the carpet underneath with the carpet around it.
- Check the stairs. The front edge of each step takes the most wear in the house. Bald or frayed noses are an early sign of the rest.
- Feel it barefoot. Hall versus closet, as above, tells you about the pad.
- Smell it on a damp day. Odors from the pad are strongest when the air is humid.
Replacing one room, or all of it
Replacing only the worn areas is possible, but new carpet next to old rarely matches, even in the same product, because dye lots differ and the old carpet has faded and worn. Changes are easiest at a doorway, a change of room or a change of material. Matching flooring through the house covers where a change of floor looks deliberate and where it looks patched.
Replacing carpet is also the moment to ask whether every room should stay carpet. Many people keep carpet in bedrooms and move the hall, living areas and stairs to a hard surface. Carpet or LVP goes room by room.
Have us take a look
At a free in-home estimate we look at the carpet you have, tell you plainly whether it is worth cleaning, repairing or replacing, and bring samples to see in your own light. If it is time, what carpet installation costs explains where the money goes, and our carpet is power-stretched, not kicked in. Every install carries a ten year labor warranty on top of the manufacturer's warranty on your materials, and financing through Wisetack is available.
Norman's has been flooring houses on Portland's Westside from Newberg since 1978. Visit the showroom at 900 Industrial Parkway, Monday to Friday, 9am to 5pm, call (503) 538-8242, or book a free estimate online.
Related services: carpet, luxury vinyl plank flooring and stairs and trim.