Somebody walks across the bedroom upstairs and it sounds like they are in the living room with you. Or the new plank floor looks great but every step clicks. Both are common reasons people ask us about quieter flooring, and they are not the same problem.
Flooring can do a lot about noise. It cannot do everything, and knowing which kind of noise you have is the first step.
Two kinds of floor noise
Impact noise is the sound of something striking the floor, footsteps, a dropped toy, a chair dragged back, traveling down through the structure into the room below. This is the one that bothers the people downstairs, or the neighbors under a condo.
In-room noise is how the floor sounds to the person standing on it. A hard floor over a thin underlayment can sound hollow or clicky, and a room full of hard surfaces echoes. This is the one that bothers the person who just paid for the floor.
The fixes overlap, but not completely. A floor can be quiet for the room below and still sound loud in the room itself, and the other way round.
What IIC and STC mean
If you live in a condo or are shopping for underlayment, you will see two ratings.
- IIC, impact insulation class, measures how well a floor and ceiling assembly blocks impact noise such as footsteps. Higher is quieter.
- STC, sound transmission class, measures how well it blocks airborne sound such as voices and television. Higher is quieter.
Both describe the whole assembly, from the floor surface down through the subfloor, the joists and the ceiling below. That is why the same underlayment can test differently in different buildings, and why a number printed on an underlayment box is a guide rather than a promise for your house.
For multifamily buildings, the model building code most US jurisdictions adopt sets a minimum of 50 for both ratings between dwelling units in new construction. Many condo associations also write their own flooring rules, often requiring a specific underlayment or a minimum rating before a hard floor can replace carpet. If you live in a condo, read your association rules before choosing a floor. We can work from the requirement once you have it.
How the floors compare
Carpet: the quietest floor there is
Carpet over a good pad absorbs impact at the surface, before it ever reaches the structure, and soaks up sound in the room too. Nothing else comes close for bedrooms over living space or for a condo where the neighbors below are close. The pad does much of the work, so a denser pad helps with noise as well as wear. Choosing carpet that lasts covers how to pick both.
Luxury vinyl plank: depends on the build
Vinyl plank varies a lot. A thin, flexible plank over a bare subfloor can sound hollow. A thicker rigid core plank, especially one with an attached acoustic pad, sounds more solid underfoot and does better for the room below.
Glue-down vinyl plank is usually quieter in the room than a floating floor, because there is no air gap for the plank to tap against. Floating plank with the right underlayment can do better for impact noise to the room below. Glue-down or floating vinyl plank goes into which suits which room.
Laminate: usually the loudest in the room
Laminate has a hard, dense core and floats over an underlayment, which gives it the most noticeable click and the most hollow sound of the common floors. A good acoustic underlayment makes a real difference, and so does a properly flat subfloor, because a laminate floor bridging a dip will drum. Laminate vs luxury vinyl plank compares the two on more than sound.
Tile: hard, and needs help over living space
Tile is bonded to the floor, so it does not click, but it passes impact noise straight down into the structure and makes a room echo. In a condo or over a finished room, tile is usually set over a sound-reducing membrane made for the purpose.
The underlayment matters as much as the floor
For floating floors, the underlayment is where most of the sound control lives.
- Use what the manufacturer specifies. Many vinyl planks come with a pad already attached. Adding a second underlayment under those is usually not allowed and can void the warranty, because the extra cushion lets the locking joints flex and fail. Reading a flooring warranty covers what else can.
- Better is denser, not thicker. A thick, soft underlayment can feel nice for a week and then let the floor move. A denser acoustic underlayment does more for sound without that risk.
- In a condo, the underlayment is often what the association rule is really about, so the specification has to match it.
Fix the subfloor while it is open
A lot of floor noise is not the floor at all. A squeak or a creak usually comes from the subfloor moving against the nails or the joists. With the old floor up, we can screw the subfloor down where it moves and deal with high and low spots, which also stops a new floating floor from drumming over a dip. Once the new floor is down, that chance is gone. What we find under your old floor goes through what we check.
Small things that help
- Area rugs with a proper rug pad in living rooms and bedrooms, especially on hard floors over living space. Use a pad that is safe for your floor; some rubber-backed rugs can discolor vinyl.
- Felt pads on chair and table legs, which take most of the scrape and bang out of a dining room.
- Soft furnishings, curtains, upholstered furniture and bookshelves, which cut echo in a room with a hard floor.
- Carpet on the stairs. A hard staircase is one of the noisiest surfaces in a house. Stair flooring weighs that against the look.
What a new floor cannot fix
Some noise goes around the floor rather than through it. Sound traveling through ductwork, around recessed lights, through a shared wall or down a stairwell is not solved by any floor covering. Neither is a floor framed so lightly that it bounces. If the problem is serious and structural, a new floor is one part of the answer, not all of it, and we would rather tell you that up front.
Hear it before you choose
Bring us the room, the floor below it and, if you are in a condo, the association rules. We bring samples to your home, talk through the underlayment along with the floor, and check the subfloor before quoting. Norman's has been installing floors from Newberg since 1978, and every install carries a ten year labor warranty on top of the manufacturer's warranty on your materials.
Visit the showroom at 900 Industrial Parkway, Monday to Friday, 9am to 5pm, call (503) 538-8242, or book a free estimate online.
Related services: carpet, luxury vinyl plank flooring, laminate and tile.